Material Comparison: COVER RAIN PROTECTION BREATH ABILITY* DIRT & DUST PROTECTION SNOW & ICE PROTECTION AIR POLLUTANTS INTERNAL HEAT REDUCTION WARRANTY BUDGE LITE® GOOD EXCELLENT VERY GOOD GOOD GOOD GOOD 2 YR PREMIER® EXCELLENT VERY GOOD EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT SUPERIOR 5 YR DURO EXCELLENT VERY GOOD EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT SUPERIOR 5 YR THE SHIELD® SUPERIOR SUPERIOR SUPERIOR SUPERIOR SUPERIOR EXCELLENT 10 YR RAIN BARRIER SUPERIOR SUPERIOR SUPERIOR SUPERIOR SUPERIOR EXCELLENT 10 YR THE MAX® MAXIMUM MAXIMUM MAXIMUM MAXIMUM MAXIMUM EXCEL